Medicare Insurance Ratings

Medicare Insurance Criteria 

  • Trustpilot Ratings. Trustpilot is considered reliable due to its open platform allowing a wide range of customer feedback, verification processes to confirm the authenticity of reviews, and a strong commitment to transparency. 
  • Company Accessibility. Good company accessibility is crucial, especially for health-related inquiries. We look at the company’s reputation for customer support, availability of help (online, phone, in-person), and the ease of filing claims or resolving issues. 
  • Educational Resources. We evaluate whether the company provides educational resources and decision-making tools to help you understand your Medicare options. 
  • Area of Service. We look at the areas where each company offers its services, so you can know if they offer plans in your area. 
  • Extra Benefits and Wellness Programs. We look at extra perks the companies offer like fitness programs, transportation to medical appointments, or wellness benefits.  
  • Financial Stability. We research the financial stability of the insurance company. This can be important for ensuring they can meet their obligations and continue to provide coverage. 
Company

Reviews

RatingFeatures & Benefits
Blue cross blue shield medicare logo
Blue Cross Blue Shield		76 Reviews | Bad8.3/10
  • A+ Rating from the Better Business Bureau (BBB)
  • Offers Medicare Advantage Plans in 50 States
  • Offers Medicare Supplement Plans in 50 States
  • Top-Rated Medicare Plans
  • Processing Medicare Claims Since 1966
Visit Site
Cigna logo
Cigna		679 Reviews | Bad9/10
  • Medicare Advantage Plans Available in 29 States
  • Medicare Supplement Plans Available in 48 States
  • Prescription Drug Plans Available in 50 States
  • More Than 200 Years of Experience in Insurance Industry
  • Flexible Plans to Meet a Variety of Needs
Visit Site
United healthcare logo
United Healthcare		297 Reviews | Bad9/10
  • Medicare Supplement Plans Available in All 50 States
  • Prescription Drug Plans Available in All 50 States
  • Also Offers Medicare Advantage Plans
  • Top-Rated Medicare Plans
  • Offers Plans with $0 Copays for Doctor Visits, Low Copays for Specialists
Visit Site
mutual of omaha insurance logo
Mutual of Omaha Medicare		93 Reviews | Bad7.3/10
  • Swift and efficient handling of claims
  • Comprehensive Medicare Supplement Options
  • Extensive Prescription Drug Coverage
  • High Customer Satisfaction Ratings on Independent Review Sites
  • More Than 100 Years of Expertise in the Insurance Industry
Visit Site
kaiser logo
Kaiser Permanente		228 Reviews | Poor7.67/10
  • Medicare Advantage Plans in 9 States
  • Part D Prescription Drug Plans
  • Above Average Customer Satisfaction Scores (J.D. Power)
  • $0 Annual Deductible
  • Customer Service Available 7 Days Per Week
  • Offering Health Insurance Plans Since 1945
Visit Site

Last updated: 11/13/25