Medicare Insurance Ratings

Medicare Insurance Criteria 

  • Trustpilot Ratings. Trustpilot is considered reliable due to its open platform allowing a wide range of customer feedback, verification processes to confirm the authenticity of reviews, and a strong commitment to transparency. 
  • Company Accessibility. Good company accessibility is crucial, especially for health-related inquiries. We look at the company’s reputation for customer support, availability of help (online, phone, in-person), and the ease of filing claims or resolving issues. 
  • Educational Resources. We evaluate whether the company provides educational resources and decision-making tools to help you understand your Medicare options. 
  • Area of Service. We look at the areas where each company offers its services, so you can know if they offer plans in your area. 
  • Extra Benefits and Wellness Programs. We look at extra perks the companies offer like fitness programs, transportation to medical appointments, or wellness benefits.  
  • Financial Stability. We research the financial strength and stability of the insurance company. This can be important for ensuring they can meet their obligations and continue to provide coverage. 
Company

Reviews

RatingFeatures & Benefits
Blue cross blue shield medicare logo
Blue Cross Blue Shield		21 Reviews | Poor8.0/10
  • A+ Rating from the Better Business Bureau (BBB)
  • Offers Medicare Advantage Plans in 50 States
  • Offers Medicare Supplement Plans in 50 States
  • Top-Rated Medicare Plans
  • Processing Medicare Claims Since 1966
Visit Site
Cigna logo
Cigna		484 Reviews | Bad7.6/10
  • Medicare Advantage Plans Available in 29 States
  • Medicare Supplement Plans Available in 48 States
  • Prescription Drug Plans Available in 50 States
  • More Than 200 Years of Experience in Insurance Industry
  • Flexible Plans to Meet a Variety of Needs
Visit Site
United healthcare logo
United Healthcare		144 Reviews | Bad6.67/10
  • Medicare Supplement Plans Available in All 50 States
  • Prescription Drug Plans Available in All 50 States
  • Also Offers Medicare Advantage Plans
  • Top-Rated Medicare Plans
  • Offers Plans with $0 Copays for Doctor Visits, Low Copays for Specialists
Visit Site
mutual of omaha insurance logo
Mutual of Omaha Medicare		47 Reviews | Bad7.25/10
  • Swift and efficient handling of claims
  • Comprehensive Medicare Supplement Options
  • Extensive Prescription Drug Coverage
  • High Customer Satisfaction Ratings on Independent Review Sites
  • More Than 100 Years of Expertise in the Insurance Industry
Visit Site
kaiser logo
Kaiser Permanente		134 Reviews | Bad6.2/10
  • Medicare Advantage Plans in 9 States
  • Part D Prescription Drug Plans
  • Above Average Customer Satisfaction Scores (J.D. Power)
  • $0 Annual Deductible
  • Customer Service Available 7 Days Per Week
  • Offering Health Insurance Plans Since 1945
Visit Site

Last updated: 1/31/24